Our goal is to help people in the best way possible. this is a basic principle in every case and cause for success. contact us today for a free consultation.
Practice Areas
Newsletter
Sign up to our newsletter
Australia-wide · No win, no fee · Free case evaluation — speak to us today
Insurance Professional Negligence
You trusted a professional to make sure you were protected. You paid your premiums every year. And then — when the flood came, the fire happened, the business ground to a halt, or you got seriously ill — you found out the policy wasn’t what you thought it was.
That isn’t always just bad luck. When a licensed insurance broker or agent gets your coverage wrong — recommending the wrong product, failing to disclose a material exclusion, letting your policy lapse without warning — that can amount to professional negligence. And if it does, you may be entitled to compensation.
UNDERSTANDING YOUR RIGHTS
Insurance professional negligence occurs when a licensed broker, agent, or financial adviser gives advice — or fails to give advice — that falls below the standard a competent professional in their position should meet, and that failure causes you financial harm.
Under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), insurance brokers operating under an Australian Financial Services licence are legally required to act in your best interest and give you advice that is appropriate to your circumstances. That’s not a courtesy — it’s a legal obligation. When they don’t meet it, there are consequences.
Brokers and agents are not the same — and the difference matters legally
An insurance broker works for you. Their job is to understand your risk, find suitable coverage, and make sure you understand what you’re buying. An insurance agent represents an insurer — they’re authorised to sell that insurer’s products, but their primary relationship is with the company, not the client.
A broker who gives you unsuitable advice is liable to you as their client. An agent who misrepresents a policy’s terms can also give rise to a claim — but the legal pathway differs. Knowing which type of professional you were dealing with is usually the first question we work through.
WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE IN PRACTICE
Insurance negligence rarely announces itself. Most people don’t discover it until a claim is denied or a payout falls dramatically short. These are the situations our team sees most often.
The policy excluded the exact risk you were exposed to
Your broker told you the commercial policy covered natural events. When the flood came, you lodged your claim — and the insurer pointed to a flood exclusion buried in the product disclosure statement. Your broker never mentioned it. That exclusion went to the very heart of what you were paying to protect.
You weren’t told about material exclusions before you signed
A licensed broker has a professional obligation to draw your attention to exclusions that could meaningfully affect whether the policy suits your situation. If they handed you a policy without walking you through what it doesn’t cover, that’s a problem.
You were told you were adequately covered — you weren’t
Your broker assessed your assets and told you the sum insured was appropriate. After a total loss, the payout covered less than half of what it actually cost to rebuild. Underinsurance caused by negligent advice is one of the most common and most devastating forms of broker failure.
Your agent submitted incorrect information on the application
The insurer denied your claim or voided your policy because the application contained material misstatements. But you didn’t fill it out — your agent did. Errors made by the agent in preparing an application are their responsibility, not yours.
Your policy lapsed because your broker didn’t handle the renewal
There was a gap between your old policy expiring and the new one commencing. A loss occurred during that window. Nobody told you. If your broker was responsible for managing renewals and let coverage lapse without notifying you, that can give rise to a claim.
The product recommended didn’t match your disclosed circumstances
You told your financial adviser you were self-employed with variable income and dependents. The income protection product they recommended was structured in a way that made it effectively worthless to someone in your position. When you needed to claim, the policy simply didn’t respond.
ASSESSING YOUR SITUATION
To establish a professional negligence claim against a broker or agent, four things generally need to be shown. Our team assesses all four during your free case evaluation.
1. Duty of care
Licensed insurance brokers and advisers owe a duty of care to their clients by law. Under ASIC’s licensing framework and the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), they must act in your best interest and give advice appropriate to your circumstances — regardless of whether you engaged them directly or through an intermediary.
2. Breach of duty
Did their advice, conduct, or failure to act fall below what a competent insurance professional in the same position should have done? Recommending an unsuitable product, failing to disclose a material exclusion, or allowing a lapse in coverage without notifying you are all examples of conduct that can constitute a breach.
3. Causation
The breach has to have actually caused your loss. If the broker had recommended the right policy, would your claim have been paid? If they’d disclosed the exclusion, would you have chosen something different? The causal link between what they did and what you lost is central to the claim.
4. Measurable financial loss
You need to be able to quantify the harm — a denied claim, an underpaid settlement, costs to repair what should have been covered, lost business income, or premiums paid for a policy that would never have responded. All of these can form the basis of a damages claim.
A note on AFCA: The Australian Financial Complaints Authority provides a free external dispute resolution service for insurance disputes. An AFCA complaint and a civil negligence claim are separate processes — and depending on your circumstances, both pathways may be available. Our team can advise which one suits your situation best.
WHO IS RESPONSIBLE
WHAT YOU CAN RECOVER
Compensation in a professional negligence claim aims to put you in the position you would have been in if the negligent advice had never been given. Depending on the facts of your situation, recoverable losses may include:
The scope of your recoverable loss depends on the specific facts — what advice was given, what policy was placed, and what that failure actually cost you. Our experienced legal team works through this carefully with every client.
THE PROCESS
The process is more straightforward than most people expect. Here’s how it typically works.
Gather everything you have
Emails, letters, policy documents, renewal notices, statements of advice, and any written communication from your broker or agent. If advice was given verbally, write down what you remember — what was said, when, and who was present.
Get a copy of your statement of advice
If your broker or financial adviser was required to provide a statement of advice, request a copy if you don’t already have it. This document sets out the advice given and the reasoning behind it, and it’s often central to establishing whether a breach occurred.
Consider whether AFCA is an option
AFCA handles insurance disputes up to $1.085 million for most general insurance matters. If your dispute is primarily with the insurer, AFCA can be a faster first step. For broker negligence or losses exceeding that threshold, civil proceedings may be more appropriate. We’ll advise you on which pathway suits your situation.
Get a free case evaluation
Our specialist professional negligence lawyers will review the advice you received, the policy you were placed in, and the loss you suffered — and give you an honest assessment of whether you have a viable claim. No obligation, fully confidential.
Legal assessment of breach, causation, and loss
Our team will assess whether the professional’s conduct fell below the required standard, whether it caused your loss, and what compensation you may be entitled to.
Letter of demand or formal proceedings
Many insurance negligence matters resolve through negotiation — often with the professional’s indemnity insurer — before reaching court. Where a fair resolution can’t be reached, our team will pursue it through the appropriate court.
Resolution
Your matter concludes by negotiated settlement or court determination, and you receive the compensation you’re entitled to.
In most Australian states, professional negligence claims must generally be commenced within 3 years of the date you became aware — or reasonably should have become aware — of the negligence. For some states, a longer general limitation period may apply, but that doesn’t mean you have unlimited time.
Insurance negligence claims can be particularly time-sensitive where a claim was denied some time ago and the underlying event occurred years before that. If you’re not sure whether your limitation period is still open, contact our team for a free assessment as soon as possible. Missing that deadline permanently extinguishes your right to claim — there’s no discretion to extend it in most circumstances.
WHY FAIR GO AUSTRALIA
We’re specialist professional negligence lawyers — not a general practice that occasionally takes on negligence matters when they come through the door. Insurance professional negligence is a defined part of what we do, and that focus matters when it comes to assessing your claim accurately from the outset.
EXPLORE THE INSURANCE SILO
Select the page that best describes your situation for more detailed information about that type of claim.
For clients who received unsuitable advice from a licensed broker — including failures to disclose exclusions, significant underinsurance, or a product that simply didn't match their circumstances.
For clients whose life, trauma, TPD, or income protection claim was denied because of negligent advice about how the policy was structured, applied for, or managed.
For clients who suffered additional loss because a claims manager or loss assessor mishandled the claims process — through unreasonable delays, incorrect assessments, or conduct that killed a valid claim.
For clients whose claim was denied or policy voided due to errors or misrepresentations made by an insurance agent or authorised representative.
For workers or employers who received negligent advice about a workers' compensation claim or policy — including failure to lodge correctly or mismanagement of an existing claim.
For clients who discovered they were dramatically underinsured after a loss — where the sum insured was set negligently low, or the coverage recommended was wholly inadequate for their circumstances.
In most Australian states, professional negligence claims must generally be commenced within 3 years of the date you became aware — or reasonably should have become aware — of the negligence. For some states, a longer general limitation period may apply, but that doesn’t mean you have unlimited time.
Insurance negligence claims can be particularly time-sensitive where a claim was denied some time ago and the underlying event occurred years before that. If you’re not sure whether your limitation period is still open, contact our team for a free assessment as soon as possible. Missing that deadline permanently extinguishes your right to claim — there’s no discretion to extend it in most circumstances.
We respond to all enquiries within 1 business day.
COMMON QUESTIONS
It depends on why the claim was denied. If it was denied because the policy your broker recommended didn’t cover the risk you specifically asked them to protect you against — and a competent broker would have known that — that can amount to negligence. If the denial was based on your own undisclosed information or a policy exclusion your broker properly disclosed to you, the situation is different. A free case evaluation will help clarify which applies to your situation.
An insurance broker holds their own Australian Financial Services licence and is legally required to act in your best interest. They work for you. An insurance agent represents an insurer — they’re authorised to sell or administer that insurer’s products. The key difference is who each professional works for, and that determines the nature of the duty they owe you. It’s one of the first things we work through when assessing an insurance negligence claim.
AFCA is Australia’s external dispute resolution service for financial services and insurance complaints. It’s free, independent, and can handle disputes up to $1.085 million for most general insurance matters. It’s often the right first step when the dispute is with the insurer directly. Where the negligence lies with a broker or adviser rather than the insurer, or where your loss exceeds AFCA’s limits, civil litigation may be more appropriate. We’ll tell you honestly which route makes more sense for your situation.
The clearest sign is that you suffered a financial loss — a denied claim, an inadequate payout, a period of uninsured exposure — that you would not have suffered if you’d received competent advice. If you weren’t told about a material exclusion, if the sum insured was set far too low, or if the product recommended simply didn’t suit the circumstances you disclosed, those are all indicators worth investigating. Our team can assess your situation in a free evaluation and give you a direct view of whether there’s a viable claim.
Not necessarily. The fact that you signed the policy doesn’t automatically defeat a negligence claim against your broker. A licensed broker has a professional obligation to draw your attention to material exclusions — particularly those that affect the core reason you took out the policy in the first place. If they failed to do that, your signature on the document may not be the end of the story. This is a fact-specific question our team can advise you on.
Yes, in many cases. If your broker was responsible for managing your insurance renewals and allowed your coverage to lapse without notifying you — and a loss occurred during that gap — they may have breached their duty of care. Where that’s established, you may be entitled to recover the amount an appropriate policy would have paid. The timeline and communications between you and your broker are usually the key evidence. Contact us for a free assessment as soon as possible if this is your situation.
Our goal is to help people in the best way possible. this is a basic principle in every case and cause for success. contact us today for a free consultation.
Sign up to our newsletter