Our goal is to help people in the best way possible. this is a basic principle in every case and cause for success. contact us today for a free consultation.
Practice Areas
Newsletter
Sign up to our newsletter
Insurance Hub
If a professional has caused you harm — through bad advice, a critical error, or a failure to act — their professional indemnity insurance is almost certainly the mechanism that will fund any compensation you recover. Understanding how PI insurance works, and what it means for your claim, puts you in a stronger position before you take any action.
Legal Concept
Professional indemnity insurance is a type of business insurance that protects professionals against claims arising from negligent advice, errors, or omissions in the course of their professional duties. In Australia, many regulated professions are legally required to hold PI insurance before they can practise. If a court finds a professional liable for negligence, their PI policy — not the professional personally — typically pays the compensation.
Mandatory PI coverage is required as a condition of registration or licensing across most regulated professions. A professional who cannot demonstrate adequate cover may be unable to practise legally.
Why it matters
When a professional’s mistake costs you money, your health, or your future, the question of whether you will actually be compensated matters enormously. Many individual professionals — even experienced ones — could not personally satisfy a significant damages award. PI insurance closes that gap.
In practical terms, this means your compensation is backed by an insurer with the financial capacity to pay. It also means the insurer — not the professional directly — will typically manage the defence of any claim made against their policyholder.
This should not discourage you. Australian law is clear that being insured does not reduce a professional’s obligation to act with reasonable care. Pursuing a legitimate claim against a PI-insured professional is not only viable — it is the normal pathway to compensation.
Who must be insured
The following professions are among those required to hold PI insurance as a condition of registration or licensing:
Even in professions where PI insurance is not strictly mandated, reputable practitioners typically hold it. If you are unsure whether the professional who harmed you carries PI coverage, we can assist with that inquiry as part of a free case evaluation.
Coverage explained
In most cases, yes — PI insurance is specifically designed to respond to claims arising from negligence in the provision of professional services. However, cover is not unlimited, and certain claims may fall outside a policy’s scope.
Where a claim falls outside the insurer’s cover — or where the policy limit is insufficient — there may still be pathways available to you. These are discussed below.
The claims process
From your perspective as the claimant, the PI insurance framework operates largely in the background. Here is how the process typically unfolds:
Having an experienced professional negligence lawyer on your side is important throughout this process. Insurer-backed defences are often well-resourced and strategically managed. You should be too.
Uninsured & underinsured
There are situations where PI insurance may not fully protect you.
In some unregulated industries — or where a professional has let their cover lapse — there may be no PI policy in place. You may still be able to pursue the professional personally through the courts. The viability of this depends on the professional’s personal financial position.
If your loss exceeds the professional’s policy limit, you may be entitled to seek the excess from the professional personally. Your lawyer will assess whether this is a realistic prospect.
If the insurer disputes liability under the policy — for example, because the professional failed to notify the claim in time, or because the conduct falls outside the policy terms — the professional may need to defend the claim personally.
If you are concerned that the professional who harmed you may be uninsured or underinsured, contact our team. We assess each situation individually and can advise on the most practical pathway forward.
In most Australian states and territories, professional negligence claims must generally be commenced within three years of the date you became aware — or reasonably should have become aware — of the negligence. This discovery rule varies by state. Missing your limitation period can permanently extinguish your right to claim.
If you are uncertain whether your limitation window is still open, contact our team for a free assessment as soon as possible.
Case law
In this landmark High Court decision, a surgeon was found liable for failing to warn a patient of a rare but material risk of blindness arising from an eye operation. The Court held that a medical practitioner’s duty of care extends to informing a patient of all material risks — not merely those a “reasonable doctor” would typically disclose. Rogers v Whitaker remains the cornerstone case on informed consent in Australian professional negligence law.
The High Court found a firm of solicitors liable for failing to locate and inform the executrix of a will they held in safekeeping for some seven years after the testator’s death. The solicitors’ PI insurer ultimately bore the cost of the resulting loss. The case established that a professional’s duty of care can extend beyond the immediate retainer — particularly where the professional has knowledge that action is urgently required.
This foundational case on auditor negligence established that an auditor owes a duty to the company — and potentially its shareholders — to exercise reasonable skill and care. Where an auditor fails to detect fraud or material error that a competent auditor would have identified, their PI insurer may be called upon to meet a significant damages award. The case remains a key reference point for claims against accountants and auditors.
Why choose us
Professional negligence claims involving PI insurers are not simple. Insurers are experienced in managing and defending these claims, and the professionals they cover are often well-resourced.
Fair Go Australia specialises in professional negligence — and only professional negligence. Our team understands how PI insurance policies operate, how insurers approach claims, and how to build the kind of evidence-backed case that leads to fair outcomes for the people who have been harmed.
We work on a no-win, no-fee basis, meaning you do not pay our legal fees unless your claim succeeds. We offer a free, confidential case evaluation — available Australia-wide — so you can understand your position before committing to any course of action.
Take action today
A free case evaluation with our team takes no more than a few minutes and costs you nothing. We will tell you honestly whether we believe your claim has merit, and what your options are.
We respond within 1 business day.
Frequently asked questions
PI insurance covers claims arising from negligent professional advice, errors, or omissions — including defence costs and any damages awarded. It typically covers financial loss, personal injury caused by negligent professional services, and property damage attributable to professional work. It generally does not cover intentional misconduct, fraud, or liability that exceeds the policy limit.
Yes. A professional’s failure to hold PI insurance does not extinguish your right to claim. You may be able to pursue the professional personally through the courts. Depending on the profession, the absence of required insurance may also be a matter you can report to the relevant regulatory body. We recommend seeking a free case evaluation to understand your options.
In regulated professions, insurance is a condition of registration. You can contact the relevant regulatory body — such as AHPRA for health practitioners, ASIC for financial advisers, or the relevant Law Society for lawyers — to confirm whether the professional holds current registration. If you are unsure, our team can assist with this inquiry as part of a free case evaluation.
In the vast majority of cases, the insurer will appoint a lawyer to defend the claim on the professional’s behalf. You should expect to deal with the insurer’s legal representative — not the professional personally — during negotiations or proceedings. This is why having your own experienced lawyer is so important: the insurer is protecting their own financial interest, not yours.
The existence of PI insurance may affect the maximum compensation available — if your losses exceed the policy limit, recovery of the excess from the professional personally may be difficult. However, PI insurance typically increases the likelihood that any compensation awarded will actually be paid. The amount you may be entitled to claim depends on the nature and extent of your loss, not on the insurer’s policy structure.
Professional indemnity insurance responds to claims arising from the professional’s advice, services, or expertise. Public liability insurance covers third-party claims for personal injury or property damage caused by the professional’s business operations — for example, a client who trips in their office. Most claims arising from professional negligence will fall under PI insurance, not public liability.
Our goal is to help people in the best way possible. this is a basic principle in every case and cause for success. contact us today for a free consultation.
Sign up to our newsletter