Our goal is to help people in the best way possible. this is a basic principle in every case and cause for success. contact us today for a free consultation.
Practice Areas
Newsletter
Sign up to our newsletter
Litigation Process
When a professional gets it wrong — and the consequences fall on you — the idea of taking legal action can feel overwhelming. You’ve already been let down once. The last thing you need is to hand the matter over to a lawyer and have no real sense of what happens next, or when, or why.
The good news is that the process is more structured — and more navigable — than most people expect. And the other thing worth knowing early: most professional negligence claims never see the inside of a courtroom. Many resolve well before that. But understanding the full pathway from the start helps you make clearer decisions at every stage.
Fair Go Australia works exclusively on professional negligence claims across Australia. Here’s how the process actually works.
The Foundation
Before anything else, it helps to understand what a professional negligence claim actually requires.
The law asks four questions. Did the professional owe you a duty of care? Did they breach that duty by falling below the accepted standard? Did that breach cause your loss? And is the loss you suffered the kind the law will compensate?
The High Court’s decision in Rogers v Whitaker (1992) 175 CLR 479 established that professionals are held to an objective standard — what a reasonably competent practitioner in that field would have done. That standard applies whether the professional is a solicitor, a doctor, a financial adviser, an accountant, or an engineer.
All four elements need to be present. A professional can make a genuine mistake without that mistake giving rise to a compensable claim. That initial assessment — of whether the elements stack up — is where any serious claim begins.
Step 1
Before anything is sent to the other side, there’s groundwork to do.
This stage involves reviewing the material you have — contracts, correspondence, advice documents, clinical records, financial statements, whatever is relevant to your situation — and identifying where the professional’s conduct departed from what was reasonably required.
It also involves checking your limitation period. There are time limits on how long you have to commence a professional negligence claim, and they vary depending on the type of claim and the state you’re in. This is worth knowing early, because how close the clock is running can affect what happens next and how quickly it needs to happen.
This stage can take a few weeks in a straightforward matter, or longer where the facts are complex or relevant documents need to be obtained.
Step 2
Once there is a proper basis to assert a claim, the first formal step is usually a letter of demand — a document sent to the professional (or, in practice, their insurer) setting out the claim, the evidence relied upon, and what is sought in compensation.
This is not a threat. It is a formal, considered document that puts the other side on notice and opens the door to resolution without proceedings.
A significant number of professional negligence claims resolve at this stage. Professionals carry indemnity insurance for a reason, and insurers are often motivated to assess liability quickly and settle matters that have clear merit rather than absorb the cost of prolonged litigation.
Step 3
If the matter doesn’t resolve through pre-litigation correspondence, the next step is commencing formal proceedings by filing a statement of claim in the appropriate court.
The statement of claim is the document that formally defines the case. It identifies the parties, sets out the facts, specifies which legal duties were owed and how they were breached, and particularises the loss claimed. Getting this document right matters — the way a claim is pleaded shapes the entire proceeding that follows.
Professional negligence matters are typically commenced in the Supreme Court of the relevant state. Some matters involving federal legislation or cross-jurisdictional issues may be commenced in the Federal Court.
Step 4
Once proceedings are on foot, both parties are required to exchange documents relevant to the dispute. This is called discovery.
In a professional negligence matter, discovery can be extensive. Client files, advice records, correspondence, file notes, financial records — all of it may be relevant. Discovery is often where the clearest evidence of what the professional did (or failed to do) comes to the surface.
Running parallel to discovery, and often beginning before formal proceedings, is the process of obtaining expert evidence. Professional negligence claims almost always require an independent expert — a practitioner in the same field as the defendant — to explain what the accepted standard required and how the defendant fell short of it. Expert witnesses owe their duty to the court, not to the party that retained them. Courts take that seriously.
Step 5
At various points through the litigation — after discovery, after expert reports are exchanged, or when a trial date is set — there will be opportunities to negotiate a resolution.
Most professional negligence matters that reach the proceedings stage still resolve before trial. Mediation is common and, in some courts, effectively required before a matter is listed for hearing. A skilled mediator facilitates negotiation between the parties in a confidential setting. Many matters that looked like they would run to trial have settled at or shortly after mediation.
This isn’t a weakness in the system. Settlement, when it delivers fair compensation, is often the best outcome — faster, cheaper, and more certain than the outcome of any contested hearing.
Step 6
If the matter can’t be resolved through negotiation or mediation, it proceeds to trial.
In civil professional negligence proceedings in Australia, there is no jury. The case is heard by a judge alone, who considers the evidence, hears from witnesses (including expert witnesses), and delivers a written judgment. That judgment may include findings on liability, causation, and the quantum of any damages awarded.
Trial is the exception rather than the rule, but when a matter needs to go that far, it will. Cases with clear merit that don’t settle early often do so for tactical reasons on the defendant’s side — and a well-prepared claimant is in the strongest position to see it through.
Costs & Funding
One of the most common reasons people don’t pursue a legitimate professional negligence claim is concern about legal costs. This is understandable — litigation can be expensive.
Fair Go Australia operates on a no-win, no-fee basis for professional negligence claims. You don’t need to fund the process upfront. The commercial arrangements are explained clearly during a free case evaluation, before you make any commitment.
It’s also worth understanding that in Australian litigation, costs generally follow the event — meaning a successful claimant can often recover a proportion of their legal costs from the defendant. How that works in practice depends on the matter and the outcome.
Timeframes
There’s no single honest answer to this — but it’s worth saying what the range actually looks like, rather than giving a number that turns out to be wrong.
Matters that resolve at the pre-litigation stage — through a letter of demand and negotiation — can conclude within months. Matters that proceed through full discovery, expert evidence exchange, and mediation before settling might take one to two years. Matters that run to trial take longer again, and complex claims with multiple defendants or significant contested expert evidence can take several years from initial engagement to final judgment.
The factors that most affect duration are how quickly the defendant and their insurer engage seriously with the claim, the complexity of the expert evidence required, the volume of documents in dispute, and court availability.
None of that should discourage you. What it means is that acting sooner rather than later — particularly where limitation periods are a concern — is generally in your interest.
Why It Matters
People who understand what a professional negligence claim involves make better decisions about whether and how to pursue one. That’s not a platitude — it’s what we observe in practice.
Someone who knows the process is unlikely to drop a legitimate claim because a letter of demand goes unanswered for a few weeks. They understand that this is a stage, not a dead end. They also understand that settlement discussions require patience — that an early offer that feels insulting may simply be the opening move in a negotiation that ends in a reasonable outcome.
Conversely, understanding the process also helps people recognise when a claim isn’t strong enough to pursue — when the breach may be clear but the causation and loss elements aren’t there, or when the limitation period has passed. That knowledge is just as valuable as knowing when to proceed.
Get Started
If you’ve been through a situation where a professional has caused you genuine loss, and you’re trying to work out whether any of this applies to you, the clearest next step is a free case evaluation. It costs nothing, it’s confidential, and it will give you an honest assessment of where you stand.
Common Questions
It depends significantly on how the matter progresses. A claim resolved through pre-litigation negotiation may conclude within months. A matter that proceeds through discovery, expert evidence, and mediation before settling typically takes one to two years. Matters that run to trial take longer. The complexity of the evidence required and the defendant’s willingness to engage seriously both affect timing.
No — the majority don’t. Many resolve through a letter of demand and negotiation before any proceedings are filed. Of those that do proceed to litigation, most settle before reaching trial. A full contested hearing is the exception, not the rule, though a well-prepared claim needs to be ready to go that distance if necessary.
In Australian civil litigation, costs generally follow the event — meaning if you are unsuccessful at trial, you may be ordered to pay a proportion of the defendant’s legal costs in addition to bearing your own. This is one of the reasons it’s important to have an honest early assessment of the merits before committing to proceedings. Fair Go Australia’s no-win, no-fee structure means you won’t be paying our legal fees if the claim doesn’t succeed — but the question of adverse costs is something to discuss with your legal team.
Yes — and most claimants do. Settlement can be reached at any point: after a letter of demand, during discovery, after expert reports are exchanged, at formal mediation, or even on the steps of the court. There is no stage at which settlement becomes impossible. The goal of negotiation is to reach fair compensation without the cost, time, and uncertainty of a full hearing.
A letter of demand is a formal document sent directly to the professional or their insurer before any court proceedings are commenced. It sets out the claim and invites resolution. Filing a claim — formally, filing a statement of claim — is the step that initiates court proceedings. It involves lodging documents with the relevant court and serving them on the defendant. Many matters never need to get to the second stage.
Our goal is to help people in the best way possible. this is a basic principle in every case and cause for success. contact us today for a free consultation.
Sign up to our newsletter